e.l.f. Beauty, Inc. (ELF) 2025 Annual Report Review

Introduction
In the fiercely competitive cosmetics and skincare market, e.l.f. Beauty, Inc. (NYSE: ELF) has carved out a strong position with its value-driven, clean, vegan and cruelty-free products. Known primarily for its flagship e.l.f. Cosmetics line, the Company has expanded into skincare (e.l.f. SKIN), specialty beauty (Well People, Keys Soulcare) and the upstart Naturium brand. e.l.f. Beautyentered fiscal 2025 riding high on a dynamic growth trajectory, reporting 28% net sales growth and robust profitability. This post breaks down the 2025 Form 10-K, highlighting the business model, financial performance, key drivers, risks, and long-term outlook.

Warren.AI 💰 7.3 / 10

---

1. Business Overview

Founded in 2004, e.l.f. Beautyredefined mass cosmetics by offering prestige-caliber products at mass prices. The Companymission—“make the best of beauty accessible to every eye, lip and face”—is powered by:

• Multi-Brand Portfolio:
• e.l.f. Cosmetics (main line, mass make-up)
• e.l.f. SKIN (ingredient-focused skincare)
• Naturium (high-performance, affordable skincare)
• Well People & Keys Soulcare (plant-powered, dermatologist-developed beauty)
• Omni-Channel Distribution
• Mass retailers: Target (23% FY25 sales), Walmart (16%), Ulta (12%), Amazon (12%), others
• E-commerce direct to consumer: Company website & loyalty program (17% FY25 sales)
• International: UK, Canada, Germany (19% FY25 sales)
• Value Proposition
• Average price <$7/_product vs. mass peers >$9 and prestige >$20
• Premium quality with clean, vegan, cruelty-free, Fair-Trade Certifiedproducts
• Performance Culture
• Annual equity for all employees aligns interests
• 90% employee engagement vs. 72% consumer industry benchmark
• Innovation Speed
• Digital product pipeline, “holy grail” prestige knock-offs
• First-to-mass launches (e.g., $10 Power Grip Primer vs. $38 prestige)
• Retail Productivity
• e.l.f. is only top-5 mass cosmetics brand with its own DTC site
• 20% annual assortment turnover driven by real-time data

---

2. FY25 Financial Highlights

Net Sales

• $1.314billion in FY25 vs. $1.024billion in FY24 (+28%)
• Volume drove 26 points of growth; mix & price added 2 points

Gross Profit & Margin

• Gross profit: $935.7million vs. $724.1million in FY24 (+29%)
• Gross margin: 71.2% vs. 70.7% in FY24
• Gains from favorable FX, supply chain efficiencies

Operating Expenses

• SG&A: $777.7million vs. $574.4million in FY24 (+35%)
• SG&A / Net Sales: 59% vs. 56% in FY24
• Marketing & digital +$62.8M
• Compensation & benefits +$60.3M
• Retail fixturing +$23.1M
• Depreciation & amortization +$13.9M

Operating Income

• $158.0million vs. $149.7million in FY24 (+5.6%)
• Operating margin: 12.0% vs. 14.6% in FY24

Net Income

• $112.1million vs. $127.7million in FY24 (12% drop)
• EPS: $1.92 diluted vs. $2.21 diluted in FY24
• Effective tax rate: 23% vs. 9% in FY24 (higher discrete tax adjustments in FY24)

Liquidity & Balance Sheet

• Cash & equivalents: $148.7million vs. $108.2million in FY24
• Revolver availability: $243.3million
• Total debt: $256.7million (4.3% net leverage ratio)
• Working capital, excluding cash: $214.8million vs. $170.1M in FY24

Acquisition

• Closed October 4, 2023: Naturium for $333M ($275M cash, $58M stock)
• Added $53.4M of net sales (OctMarFY24)

---

3. Key Drivers & Metrics

• Customer Mix: 83% retailer / 17% e-commerce FY25
• Geography: 81% US / 19% International FY25
• Top 4 customers: Target, Walmart, Ulta, Amazon = ~63% of net sales
• R&D & Innovation: #Fast Company 2025 Most Innovative
• Marketing spend: $318.8M in FY25 (24% of net sales)

Seasonality

• Q3 / Q4 seasonally strongest (holidays, shelf resets)
• Q1 / Q2 planning, product launches, retailer ordering

Supply Chain

• 85%+ manufacturing in Fair-Trade Certifiedfacilities
• Redundant third-party manufacturers in China, Thailand, Taiwan, EU, USA
• 3rd party distribution in US, UK, Germany, Canada, China

---

4. Risk Factors

Industry & Competition

• Highly competitive cosmetics/skincare industry
• Price wars & deep discounting by big incumbents
• New indies, celebrity / influencer brands

Customer Concentration

• Top 4 retailers = 63% of net sales
• No guaranteed purchase contracts; shelf space is finite

Supply Chain & Tariffs

• 75% manufacturing in China; 25% US
• Subject to US 25% tariffs, higher scheduled by executive orders
• Cost inflation, port congestion, natural disasters

Consolidation & Economic Trends

• Economic downturns can cut discretionary beauty spend
• Consolidation / credit risk among retailers / suppliers

Regulatory & Legal

• FDA & FTC scrutiny of product claims (cosmetics vs. drug)
• MoCRA adoption, Good Manufacturing Practices
• ESG / corporate citizenship / supply due diligence

Intellectual Property

• Few patents; reliance on trademarks and trade secrets
• Infringement & counterfeits, brand dilution

Tech & Security

• Cybersecurity, data privacy (GDPR, CCPA)
• E-commerce / digital marketing dependence

Management & Culture

• Dependency on key executives & founders
• High demand for talent in US, China, UK

---

5. Long-Term Outlook

e.l.f. Beautystands at the intersection of value, clean beauty, and digital disruption. The Naturium acquisition bolsters its credentials in the premium skincare category. Key growth levers in the coming years include:

• Retail Expansion:
• Broader international footprint beyond US, UK, Canada
• Deeper partnerships and space gains with mass players
• DTC & Omni-Channel:
• Enhanced direct-to-consumer engagement via loyalty, personalization
• Integration of AI for consumer targeting, forecasting, supply chain optimization
• Innovation Cadence:
• Faster R&D cycles, more “holy grail” prestige-inspired launches at mass price
• Skin science (Naturium), plant-power (Well People), ritual-driven (Keys Soulcare)
• Digital Marketing:
• Social commerce, influencer tie-ups, platforms like TikTok (pending regulatory clarity)
• Next-gen brand partnerships & experiential activations
• Supply Chain Resilience:
• Mitigation of tariff exposure via diversified manufacturing
• ESG compliance across sourcing, packaging, carbon, water
• Margin Improvement:
• Scale advantages, supply efficiencies, pricing power

Challenges
Managing tariffs, retailer concentration, emerging competition and macro headwinds will test managementexecution. Currency volatility, legal/regulatory shifts and cyber risks remain ever-present.

---

6. Investment Considerations

Bull Case

• Proven track record of high-growth, shock-proof FY25 revenue +28%
• Strong gross margin, operating leverage potential at scale
• Deep digital & DTC edge, product pipeline fueled by consumer data
• ESG-friendly credentials, multi-brand synergy

Bear Case

• Retailer concentration, limited pricing flexibility
• Tariff, currency & supply chain inflation risk
• Highly competitive market, crowded premium skincare
• Elevated SG&A as % of sales slows profitability lift

Valuation & Score
ELF trades at a forward EV/EBITDA multiple in line with mass cosmetics peers, but at a premium on growth. We assign an investment score of 7.3/10:

• Strengths: Consistent double-digit growth, strong brand equity, digital moat
• Cautions: Profit margins below prestige peers, macro and tariff exposures

Disclosure: This analysis is for informational purposes only and is not financial advice. Investors should perform their own due diligence.

---

Bottom Line: e.l.f. Beautyoffers a unique value-beauty proposition, backed by disciplined execution and digital prowess. While near-term profitability will hinge on margin improvements and managing external headwinds, the Company is well-positioned for sustainable growth across beauty categories and channels.